Thursday, January 30, 2020

Why Taking Social Security at These 2 Ages Could Be a Big No-No

You probably know the size of your benefit checks will shrink if you claim early, but how much it will shrink is not entirely a straight-line calculation.
Dan Caplinger (TMFGalagan) Jan 25, 2020 at 10:03AM Author Bio
One of the most controversial questions in personal finance is when people should start taking their Social Security benefits. Yet while there will never be complete agreement about when the best time to  file for benefits is, there is at least something of a consensus about when it doesn't make sense to do so.
The age you are when you claim Social Security will have a significant impact on how big your monthly checks will be. Many people are hazy on what the calculation that determines that looks like, but if you look at the formulas, you'll see some idiosyncrasies that make certain ages less than ideal.
How claiming early hurts your benefits
When the federal government started allowing people to claim Social Security before their full retirement age, it wanted to make sure that those claiming early didn't get an unfair advantage from receiving more payments. The Social Security Administration therefore implemented a formula that reduced the size of the monthly checks that early claimants received. Those reductions were calibrated so that, assuming people lived to their average life expectancy, the total amount of money they would receive from the program would be about the same, regardless of when they chose to start receiving benefits.
At the time, the full retirement age was 65, and the SSA's rule reduced benefits by five-ninths of a percentage point for every month someone claimed early. Those claiming retirement benefits at the earliest possible age -- 62 -- would thus receive monthly payments amounting to 80% of what they'd have gotten if they had waited until they were 65. It was a straight-line rule, and it made it relatively simple to calculate how claiming early would affect your monthly checks.
Later, lawmakers implemented a slow increase in the retirement age from 65 to 67. At the same time, lawmakers changed the formula for  calculating reductions for early claimants. Beyond the first 36 months, the SSA cuts benefits by five-twelfths of a percentage point per month -- or about 0.42%, versus 0.56% for the first 36 months.
How the Social Security formula makes claiming at 63 or 64 less attractive
Because of that change, claiming Social Security at 63 or 64 won't make as much sense for many recipients as other ages. Consider the following chart, which shows how much someone with a full retirement benefit of $1,500 per month at age 66 would get based on different claiming ages:
Age Claimed
Monthly Benefit
Change Compared to Claiming One Year Earlier
62
$1,125
-
63
$1,200
6.7%
64
$1,300
8.3%
65
$1,400
7.7%
66
$1,500
7.1%
CHART BY AUTHOR.
As you can see, you get the smallest percentage increase in your monthly benefit by waiting from 62 to 63. After that, waiting an extra year gets you larger increases.
A similar thing happens for those whose full retirement age is 67:
Age Claimed
Monthly Benefit
Change Compared to Claiming One Year Earlier
62
$1,050
-
63
$1,125
7.1%
64
$1,200
6.7%
65
$1,300
8.3%
66
$1,400
7.7%
67
$1,500
7.1%
CHART BY AUTHOR.
Here, the increase from 62 to 63 is a little bigger in percentage terms, and the lowest increase comes between 63 and 64.
Wait just a little bit longer
As it happens, most people intuitively seem to understand the trade-offs involved. A huge number of Social Security recipients claim at 62, but relatively few claim at 63 and 64. Larger sets of recipients wait until either 65 or their full retirement age to claim benefits, in part because many still consider 65 the appropriate age to retire despite the changes to what Social Security deems your full retirement age.
The debate over whether it's best to claim Social Security at 62, 70, or your full retirement age will rage on, and you'll have to come to your own personal decision about what timing works best for you. But when it comes to claiming at in-between ages like 63 and 64, there are solid reasons to avoid it if you can.
The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

https://www.fool.com/retirement/2020/01/25/why-taking-social-security-at-these-2-ages-could-b.aspx

CMS clears block grants for states' Medicaid expansion


MICHAEL BRADY  January 30, 2020
The CMS on Thursday unveiled an optional demonstration that would allow states to extend Medicaid coverage to adults that don't qualify otherwise in exchange for capped funding.
Under the Healthy Adult Opportunity initiative, states could share cost savings with the federal government and extend Medicaid coverage to more residents in exchange for taking on more financial risk.
"While available funding will be capped in the aggregate, states will not have the ability to cap enrollment and still receive the enhanced federal match rate available to the expansion population," a CMS factsheet on the initiative said.
Oklahoma governor Kevin Stitt, a Republican, on Thursday said his state would apply for a Healthy Adult Opportunity waiver during an event showcasing the initiative. He said the state's application would likely include cost-sharing premiums and a work requirement, as well as higher payments for rural providers, telehealth services and greater access to opioid treatment.
But Stitt will have to win support from the state Legislature to move forward with the waiver application.
All states are eligible to participate in the initiative, which would allow states to extend Medicaid coverage to adults under 65 years old who don't qualify for Medicaid because of disability, long-term care needs or who don't qualify for a state plan. The CMS would allow participating states to change cost-sharing requirements, align benefits and drug formularies with what commercial payers offer, make program changes with less federal oversight and waive retroactive coverage and hospital presumptive eligibility requirements.
"By incentivizing value, this approach won't simply result in higher quality care for beneficiaries in the present, but will also safeguard quality care for future beneficiaries by putting the program on a sustainable path," CMS Administrator Seema Verma said on a press call Thursday.
The capped funding would be calculated by looking at a state's costs for a prior year, population and the demonstration's benefits. Federal contributions in future years would not be altered for Medicaid enrollment changes.
Families USA executive director Frederick Isasi immediately criticized the Trump administration guidance Thursday, warning that it could wreak havoc on Medicaid beneficiaries and state budgets.
"With state budgets already stretched thin, accepting Medicaid block grants could likely amount to willful fiscal malpractice and blatant disregard for the needs and interests of states and families," he said.
States don't have strong incentives to apply for a Healthy Adult Opportunity waiver because they would take on more financial risk for the expanded population without receiving much additional flexibility. Most of the flexibility afforded to states under the plan is already available under Medicaid 1115 waivers, including the ability to institute a work requirement, adjust cost-sharing or eliminate retroactive coverage.
"The notable thing is that there isn't that much new flexibility for states," said Jocelyn Guyer, managing director at Manatt Health. "At the end of the day, it's largely 'do you want to take a cap on your federal Medicaid funds.'"
Under the total expense model, states would have to spend 80% or more of the target amount on health services. If states generate savings without reducing quality or access, the federal government would share the savings with them. But states would have to give up matching federal funds in order to receive cost savings. So most state Medicaid programs would be in a worse financial position than if they went forward with a conventional Medicaid expansion.
"The state doesn't get to keep all of the savings, so you have to wonder how strong of an incentive that is," said Joseph Antos, a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
Red states could see the demonstration as a conservative approach to Medicaid expansion, but the initiative prohibits enrollment caps and partial expansions, two policy tools that many experts think would be important to making capped Medicaid funding work by containing costs.
"I think it's particularly risky for a state like Oklahoma to pursue an expansion under this kind of authority given that they're stuck with a limited amount of federal funding," Guyer said. "It's putting yourself in a very tight spot."
Most non-expansion states haven't expanded their Medicaid programs for political or ideological reasons, rather than financial ones.
"I don't see this as doing much to help a state that is feeling fiscal pressure," Antos said. "To get real savings calls for healthcare delivery reform ... it's delivery reform that's the hard part"
Hospitals and other providers are unlikely to change how they deliver healthcare because of the new demonstration because the affected population is too small for it to make an impact, he said.
The Healthy Adult Opportunity initiative isn't a traditional block grant, which isn't permitted under the CMS' waiver authority. It does little to address conservatives' concerns about Medicaid's fiscal integrity, which largely stem from improper supplemental payments.
"There's nothing in (the initiative) that's going to change that," Antos said.
Under the current system, the federal government matches state Medicaid funding dollar for dollar.
The Trump administration withdrew its proposed guidance to states on Medicaid block grants from regulatory review in November without an explanation. At the time, several experts speculated that the instructions could be long delayed or put on permanent hiatus, especially if the administration believed the proposal would increase federal spending.
"The failure to update the Medicaid program is something that this administration has felt has needed to be addressed for a long time. Absent Congressional action, Administrator Verma has vigorously worked to improve this program through administrative action," said Joe Grogan, assistant to President Donald Trump and director of the Domestic Policy Council.
Many legal experts think that the Trump administration can't use the Section 1115 waiver process to waive Medicaid's matching funds system and expect that any such effort will lead to a battle in the courts.
"I think that any state that takes this up is walking itself right into a lawsuit," Guyer said.
Politicians in Alaska, Oklahoma and Tennessee had expressed interest in converting their state Medicaid programs to a block grant. Last fall, Tennessee submitted a block grant proposal to the CMS that would allow it to receive an inflation-adjusted block grant that could be adjusted upward on a per capita basis if enrollment grows. Tennessee's request includes a broader population than what's allowed under the new guidance so the CMS is considering it separately, Verma said. The waiver is pending approval.
Tennessee will continue with its existing waiver application, but the state's Medicaid program is supportive of the new approach.
"We are excited about CMS' recognition that the misaligned incentives of Medicaid financing do not necessarily drive quality, value, or fiscal sustainability," TennCare said in a statement. "Specifically, it is encouraging that CMS recognizes that states should have the opportunity to earn shared savings through quality-based performance that can then be reinvested in their Medicaid programs and the health (not just health care) of their Medicaid members."
Conservative policymakers have previously supported replacing Medicaid's open-ended funding with block grants because they think it will incentivize states to spend Medicaid funds more judiciously and reduce federal healthcare spending. They also argue that it would give states more flexibility to respond to their unique healthcare challenges.
But many healthcare experts worry that under a block grant, states might have to slash their Medicaid rolls or payments to disproportionate-share hospitals to get program spending under control. That could lead to significant coverage losses and reduce access to care for some of the most vulne rable populations. It could also hurt doctors and hospitals by increasing the amount of uncompensated care that they provide.
In September 2017, Sens. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) and Bill Cassidy (R-La.) floated a bill that would have changed Medicaid to a block-grant program. The bill would have ended the enhanced matching rate for the Medicaid expansion and replaced it with a lump sum far below existing federal funding. It would have also instituted a per capita spending cap to replace the current system of matching funds.
The Senate never voted on it thanks to political blowback after the Congressional Budget Office said that millions of people would lose coverage if the package went into effect.

AHIP Wants ACA Court Case To Move Quickly


By Wire Reports January 24, 2020 
America’s Health Insurance Plans wants the U.S. Supreme Court to decide quickly on whether the Affordable Care Act is valid.
In an amicus, or “friend of the court” brief, AHIP requested the court “remove the overhanging  legal uncertainty that undermines the stability of coverage for nearly 300 million Americans.”
Matt Eyles, AHIP’s president and CEO, said in a statement that “Every American deserves affordable coverage and high-quality care. This has been – and always will be – our commitment.”
The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals is expected to hand down a ruling on whether the ACA is unconstitutional. Arguments centered on the Republican-led Congress’ passage of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act in 2017, which eliminated – or zeroed out - the ACA’s penalty for people who did not have health insurance. ACA opponents argue that eliminating the individual mandate penalty amounted to a government-ordered command to buy health insurance. If the penalty is unconstitutional, then the entire law must fall.
“The district court’s original decision to invalidate the entire ACA was misguided and wrong,” the AHIP statement says. The organization believes the ACA “should continue in operation despite its zeroing out of the mandate.”
“We are confident that the Supreme Court will ultimately recognize that zeroing out the mandate was never intended to wreak havoc across the entire American health care system.
“As we continue to engage in the legal process, health insurance providers remain committed to serving all of their members, and to strengthening affordability, access and choices for every American.”
The AHIP brief went on to say invalidation of the ACA “would wreak havoc on the health care system. Congress could not have intended that result in 2010, when it enacted one of the most comprehensive and far-reaching pieces of health care legislation in over 50 years. And Congress did not intend that result in 2017, when it zeroed out the tax payment for forgoing health coverage without repealing any other ACA provision.”
The ACA “is not a tapestry that unravels by pulling upon a single thread (i.e., the individual mandate),” the brief said.
“Rather, the ACA’s multitude of wide-ranging reforms, which rest on a variety of statutory foundations scattered across the U.S. Code, affect every health insurance market (not just the individual market) and every American with coverage (not just those who purchased coverage on the exchanges).”
AHIP also noted eliminating the ACA’s protections for people with pre-existing conditions “would upend the individual markets and throw individuals and health insurance providers back to an obsolete system that cannot be revived without serious disruption to American lives and the nation’s economy.”

Support Medically Necessary Oral Health Care in Medicare


For the past few years, a coalition of beneficiary advocates, disease organizations, industry groups, oral health and medical health professionals has been advocating for medically necessary oral health care to be covered by Medicare, as authorized under current law. The Coalition recently launched a web-based platform for members of the public to express their support and urge the Administration to provide critical coverage for Medicare beneficiaries for medically necessary oral health care. 

Please consider participating and spreading the word.

The platform is: https://freeroots.com/campaign/make-medicare-better.

Study Finds Nursing Home Compare Data about Patient Falls with Major Injuries Underreported and “Highly Inaccurate”


In the first “national-level assessment of how nursing homes self-report major injury fall rates, which are used by CMS for quality measurement and public reporting,” researchers “found substantial underreporting on the specific Minimum Data Set (MDS) item (J1900C) used by NHC [Nursing Home Compare].” Prachi Sanghav, Shengyuan Pan, Daryl Caudry, “Assessment of nursing home reporting of major injury falls for quality measurement on nursing home compare,” Health Services Research, p. 5.  2019;00:1-10. 

https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-6773.13247.  Only 57.5% of residents’ major injury falls that were identified in Medicare hospital admissions claims data were reported on residents’ assessment data.

Researchers analyzed 100% of major injury falls in hospital admissions claims data from the Medicare Provider Analysis and Review (MedPAR) for the period January 1, 2011 to September 30, 2015 (150,828 falls). They compared these claims data to facilities’ self-reported MDS data for the same period, focusing on J1900C (major injury during current stay), “as the responses to this question for long-stay residents are used to create an NHC quality measure and are part of the star rating algorithm.” Article 2. Researchers found:
  • Only 57.5% of the claims were reported on MDS.
  • More falls were reported on MDS for long-stay (62.9%) than for short-stay (47.2%)  residents.
  • More falls were reported on MDS for white (59.0%) than for nonwhite (46.4%) residents.
  • Long-stay white residents had the highest reporting rate (64.5%), while short-stay nonwhite residents had the lowest reporting rate (37.4%). 4.
Researchers also found poor correlations between claims-based falls rates and quality measure star ratings and overall ratings. At least 75% of the nursing facilities had a four- or five-star quality measure rating and half the facilities had four- and five-star overall ratings. Id. 4-5, Table 4.

As a matter of policy, the researchers suggest that “claims-based measures may be useful supplements or replacements for the MDS-based patient safety indicator.” Id. 6. 8.
“Assessment of nursing home reporting of major injury falls for quality measurement on nursing home compare” is available at https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/1475-6773.13247 and from the Center for Medicare Advocacy, on request.

Medicare SNF Payment Model Creates Changes in Care and Admissions – What about Facility Assessments?


The new Medicare reimbursement system for skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) – the Patient-Driven Payment Model (PDPM) – fundamentally changes the financial incentives for facilities. With PDPM, Medicare now pays lower rates for residents needing therapy and higher rates for residents needing complex nursing care. Responding to these financial incentives, SNFs laid off therapists across the country and some SNFs began actively recruiting and admitting people who use ventilators or need dialysis. The federal Requirements of Participation require facilities making changes to the types of residents they admit to update their Facility Assessment in order to assure that they have the staff and equipment that are needed to provide care for these new residents. Are SNFs doing these mandatory assessments?  If not, what can advocates do?
PDPM

In creating PDPM, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) intended to reverse the perceived overuse of therapy (and definite overbilling for therapy) under the prior reimbursement system, Resource Utilization Groups (RUG).[1] Final PDPM rules expressly confirm that PDPM financially disfavors residents needing therapy and pays lower rates to facilities providing therapy.[2]

SNFs’ Responses to PDPM

SNFs’ responses to the new financial incentives were swift. Reports in early October, days after PDPM’s October 1 effective date, indicated that thousands of therapists had lost their jobs or had their hours reduced.[3] Less public attention was focused on SNFs’ changing admissions practices – the admissions of residents using ventilators or needing dialysis – but these changes were occurring as well.

Skilled Nursing News reported in July 2019 that respiratory therapy would provide a “massive skilled nursing opportunity under PDPM” for several reasons that it identified:
  • Residents using ventilators would be assigned to the highest case mix group for the nursing component. (Note that this case mix component does not decline over the course of a resident’s stay under PDPM’s variable per day adjustment, while three other case mix categories– physical therapy, occupational therapy, and non-therapy ancillaries [chiefly drugs] – do).
  • Residents using ventilators have a greater chance of using the maximum number of days of Medicare coverage in a benefit period (100 days).
  • Residents using ventilators need just (at least) 15 minutes of time each day with a respiratory therapist or nurse.
  • SNFs can make as much as $1200-$1800 extra reimbursement each week for each resident using a ventilator.[4]
An industry analysis of the first six weeks of PDPM reported that SNFs have responded to the “massive” financial incentives presented by respiratory therapy.  Zimmit Healthcare Services Group found “[a]nother surprise – we did not expect the Special Care High group to be so well represented on day 1.  Respiratory Therapy generated well-deserved attention, with several high-profile service providers marketing RT’s potential Return on Investment.”[5]

Another special service supporting high Medicare rates is dialysis services, which Skilled Nursing News also identified as “a major growth area” under PDPM, “both financially and clinically.”[6]

Our Concerns

The Center has two concerns about SNFs’ expansion of services to ventilators and dialysis.  First, some poor quality facilities seem to be responding to PDPM’s financial incentives.  Second, we question whether SNFs are fully assuring their actual capacity to provide the necessary complex nursing care.

The Center heard reports that some poorly performing nursing facilities, including a candidate for the Special Focus Facility program, began establishing new ventilator units and actively recruiting people who use ventilators.[7] The interest of poor quality facilities in ventilator care is especially troubling in light of The New York Times’s report in September 2019 that drug-resistant infections are prevalent and deadly for residents using ventilators in nursing facilities because of facilities’ insufficient and inadequate staffing and poor infection control practices.[8]

Skilled Nursing News’ article on dialysis highlighted two facilities that had planned to add dialysis services.  One facility is a one star facility (CMS’s lowest category) and the other facility has a two-star rating in health inspections (below average), according to the federal website Nursing Home Compare. The interest of poorly performing SNFs in providing such complex care is troubling.

What Can Be Done? Facility Assessment

One response to SNFs’ expansion into ventilator and dialysis services and other complex services is to determine whether the facility has actually taken steps to ensure that it is fully prepared to meet these residents’ challenging needs. Has the facility performed the Facility Assessment?

The 2016 revisions to the federal standards of care that SNFs must meet in order to be eligible for Medicare reimbursement, the Requirements of Participation, include a new requirement for Facility Assessment.[9] The Facility Assessment requires a facility “to determine what resources are necessary to care for its residents competently during both day-to-day operations and emergencies.”[10] Assessments must address the “resident population”[11] and “facility resources,” including equipment, services, and staff.[12]  SNFs must review and update their Assessments annually and “whenever there is, or the facility plans for, any change that would require a substantial modification to any part of this assessment.”[13] CMS’s State Operations Manual gives examples of “modifications” requiring review and updating of the Assessment, such as the decision to begin admitting residents with ventilators or on dialysis who were not previously admitted.[14]

The mandate on facilities is clear, but residents’ and advocates’ role may be limited. CMS says facilities are “strongly encouraged [but not required] to seek input from the resident/family council, residents, their representative(s), or families” about a facility assessment.[15]  Only surveyors’ access to Facility Assessments is unequivocal.

What Residents and Their Advocates Can Do

Resident and their advocates can ask for a copy of the SNF’s Facility Assessment, although SNFs may decline to give them a copy. If a SNF has newly added ventilator or dialysis coverage, advocates can ask the state survey agency to determine whether the facility has complied with the Facility Assessment requirement. Advocates can also join the Center for Medicare Advocacy in asking CMS to send a Survey & Certification Letter to state survey agency directors, reminding them of the Facility Assessment requirement and encouraging them determine whether SNFs assured their ability to take on new residents needing complex care.
_______________
[1] 83 Fed. Reg. 21018, 21034-21036 (May 8, 2018) (proposed rules).
[2] 83 Fed. Reg. 39162, 39183-39265 (Aug. 8, 2018).  See especially Table 37, Impact Analysis Resident Level, at 39257-39259, and Table 38, Impact Analysis Facility Level, at 39160-39161.
[3] See Danielle Brown, ‘Therapist advocates sharing layoff concerns with CMS,” McKnight’s Long-Term Care News (Oct. 3, 2019), https://www.mcknights.com/news/therapist-advocates-sharing-layoff-concerns-with-cms/; Alex Kacik, “Therapists look to CMS for aid as SNFs restructure,” Modern Healthcare (Oct. 4, 2019), https://www.modernhealthcare.com/payment/therapists-decry-layoffs-amid-snf-reimbursement-overhaul.  See CMA, “Nursing Home Residents and Therapy Under The New Medicare Payment System” (CMA Alert, Oct. 10, 2019), https://www.medicareadvocacy.org/nursing-home-residents-and-therapy-under-the-new-medicare-payment-system/.
[4] Alex Spanko, “Respiratory Therapy’s ‘Massive Skilled Nursing Opportunity Under PDPM,” Skilled Nursing News (Jul. 28, 2019), https://skillednursingnews.com/?s=Respiratory+Therapy%27s+Massive+Skilled+Nursing+Opportunity.
[5] Zimmet Healthcare Services Group, LLC, CORE Analytics, PDPM Reimbursement Analysis: October 2019 Medicare Claims; Financial Impact, Observations, Rate Measures & Comparative Integrity, page 9 (Nov. 18, 2019), https://www.zcoreanalytics.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/PDPM-Reimbursement-Analysis-2019.pdf.
[6] Linda Yamshon, “Nursing Home Dialysis Demand Drives Post-PDPM Push to Specialty Services,” Skilled Nursing News (Nov. 25, 2019), https://skillednursingnews.com/2019/11/nursing-home-dialysis-demand-drives-post-pdpm-push-to-specialty-services/.
[7] See CMA, “Medicare’s New Skilled Nursing Facility Payment System Alters Access to Care” (CMA Alert, Nov. 7, 2019), https://www.medicareadvocacy.org/medicares-new-skilled-nursing-facility-payment-system-alters-access-to-care/.
[8] Matt Richtel, Andrew Jacobs, “Nursing Homes Are a Breeding Ground for a Fatal Fungus,” (Sep. 11, 2019), https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/11/health/nursing-homes-fungus.html?searchResultPosition=1.
[9] 42 C.F.R. §483.70(e).
[10] 42 C.F.R. §483.70(e).
[11] 42 C.F.R. §483.70(e)(1).
[12] 42 C.F.R. §483.70(e)(2).
[13] 42 C.F.R. §483.70(e).
[14] State Operations Manual, CMS Pub. , Appendix PP, (unnumbered page) 619, https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/downloads/som107ap_pp_guidelines_ltcf.pdf.
[15] Id. 618.